Roof Claim Answers

What depreciation rate does insurance apply to a roof repair?

Short answer. Insurers usually depreciate repair materials at the same rate as the rest of the roof, based on the roof's age over the material's expected life, so new shingles on a 15 year old roof are depreciated as if they were 15 years old. On many standard forms, though, repairs under 5 percent of your dwelling limit and under $2,500 are paid at full replacement cost without waiting for proof of completion.

Why a repair gets the roof's age

Depreciation reflects the value of what was damaged, not what you install. Shingles on a 15 year old roof had 15 years of wear, so a repair estimate often depreciates the shingle and underlayment lines by the same percentage the whole roof would get. Labor and incidental lines may be treated differently, so read the depreciation column on each line.

The small loss rule

Many standard homeowners forms pay full replacement cost right away when the repair costs both less than 5 percent of the building's coverage amount and less than $2,500. On a house insured for $350,000, an $1,800 repair qualifies; a $3,000 repair does not.

The deductible usually decides it

Most single area repairs, such as a few shingles or a pipe boot, cost less than a typical deductible, especially a percentage wind and hail deductible. A repair claim makes more sense when the damage is spread across slopes or water got inside.

Repair or replace

If hail or wind hit several slopes, or the shingles are too brittle to repair without breaking more, a repair estimate may understate the loss. Discontinued shingles that cannot be matched raise the issues in partial roof replacement and matching. See also percentage deductibles.

If you meant taxes

On a rental, a true repair is usually deducted in the year you pay for it rather than depreciated.

In depth

What is the difference between ACV and RCV on a roof claim?Actual cash value vs replacement cost value on a Georgia roof claim, with a labeled example showing depreciatiWhat is a roof insurance supplement, and what usually gets missed?A roof supplement adds items the first estimate missed: drip edge, starter, ice and water, steep and high charWhen does insurance pay overhead and profit on a roof claim?Overhead and profit (O&P) on roof claims: why estimate prices exclude it, when carriers usually pay it for gen

People also ask