Roof Claim Answers

Does a metal roof lower your insurance?

Short answer. It can, but not automatically. Some insurers credit metal roofs, especially products rated Class 4 for impact under UL 2218 or with strong wind ratings, while others price them like shingles or add a cosmetic damage exclusion that limits what they will pay for dents. Ask your agent for the actual premium difference and any endorsement before you buy.

Why insurers may give a credit

The catch: cosmetic damage exclusions

Hail dents metal long before it leaks. Many insurers attach a cosmetic damage exclusion to metal roofs, so a roof full of dents is not paid as long as it still sheds water. A modest premium credit can cost far more if you are left with a dented roof after a big storm. See the cosmetic damage exclusion.

Cost versus savings

A metal roof usually costs substantially more than an architectural shingle roof. Compare that difference with the yearly premium savings your agent quotes in writing, and remember a discount can change at renewal. Impact-resistant shingles are another route to a credit where insurers offer one, usually at a lower upfront cost.

Questions for your agent

  1. What is the exact annual premium with metal versus my current roof?
  2. Will a cosmetic damage exclusion be added?
  3. What proof is required: invoice, product certificate, permit?

See also roof age and insurance and hail size and roof damage.

In depth

What is a cosmetic damage exclusion on a roof, and does my policy have one?What a cosmetic damage exclusion says, why it hits metal roofs hardest, how to find one in your Georgia policyDoes homeowners insurance cover interior water damage from a roof leak?When interior damage from a roof leak is covered: storm openings, gradual leak exclusions, mold limits, and whDoes insurance pay for building code upgrades when your roof is replaced?How ordinance or law coverage pays for roof code upgrades in Georgia: drip edge, underlayment, ice barrier whe

People also ask