Roof Claim Answers

What is the depreciation life of a metal roof?

Short answer. For insurance, metal roofs are depreciated against long expected lives, commonly 40 years or more depending on the panel type, so they lose value far more slowly than shingles. For taxes, a metal roof on a rental is depreciated over 27.5 years like any other roof, or 39 years on nonresidential property.

Insurance: slower depreciation

Because adjusters divide age by expected life, a long life means small yearly depreciation. A 10 year old metal roof given a 50 year life is depreciated 20 percent, while a 10 year old shingle roof given 25 to 30 years is a third or more. Exposed fastener panels are often given shorter lives than standing seam, because the screws and washers wear out long before the panels.

The bigger issue on metal: cosmetic dents

Hail often dents metal without letting water in. Many policies now carry a cosmetic damage exclusion that refuses to pay for dents that do not affect how the roof works. On metal, that exclusion usually matters far more than the depreciation rate. Punctures, split seams and broken fasteners are functional damage and remain covered, and disputes over whether cracked paint or coating counts as functional are common.

Payment schedules

If your policy has a roof payment schedule, metal usually has its own column that declines more slowly than shingles. Check the table rather than assuming.

Tax depreciation

For how metal holds up in this climate, see metal roofing in Georgia, and for the basics of claim depreciation, ACV vs RCV.

In depth

How do you read an Xactimate roof estimate from your insurance company?Reading an Xactimate roof estimate: line items, SQ, LF and EA units, remove vs replace, waste, regional monthlWhat is the difference between ACV and RCV on a roof claim?Actual cash value vs replacement cost value on a Georgia roof claim, with a labeled example showing depreciatiHow do you get recoverable depreciation released on a roof claim?How a roof claim's depreciation holdback is released: final invoice, proof of completion, policy time limits l

People also ask